Posted on September 11, 2009 by Paul Ritchie
The hottest Crossderry search term over the last few weeks has been “Dodge Caliber”, which brings folks to my “Benefits vs. Disbenefits” post. Probably not quite the take that most link followers expected, but the image does point them to Eric Beckinger’s cri de coeur.
I guess I should opine briefly on why I empathized w/ Eric’s rant: I had just rented a Dodge Caliber. The shape had intrigued me when I first saw it on the road. And though I had read a number of negative reviews, I was eager to give it a whirl once I saw it was my week’s rental.
Frankly, once you look past the profanity, Eric may be understanding the poverty of the Caliber driving experience. It wasn’t just bad, it was depressing. My mantra while driving it was “I’m so glad I didn’t get close to buying one of these.”
Oh, and I kept thinking back to the time I drove a Trabi…
Filed under: PMO | Tagged: benefits, benefits realization, disbenefits, Dodge Caliber, Eric Beckinger, Trabant, Trabi | Leave a comment »
Posted on May 2, 2009 by Paul Ritchie
Click to read Eric Beckinger's post on why this car shouldn't exist...
As we build the value management components of the next generation of SAP methodologies, I’ve dug in to the program management standards of PMI and OGC. One of our first principles is to ensure alignment with industry standards; however, for programs and value management we’ll need to mix and match.
One example of a concept not in both standards is the idea of “disbenefits” in OGC’s Managing Successful Programmes (benefits profile outline here). The concept is illustrated in my comment below about a Dodge Caliber rental…
I still can’t get over how bad the Dodge Caliber was to drive…however, a short test drive could fool the unwary. Only a bean-counter would think it was a good idea to keep building Calibers. What is more valuable: the additional amortization of the Caliber tooling you get by selling more cars or the lasting emnity of the folks who buy them?
And that’s why considering disbenefits makes all the difference…
Filed under: PMO | Tagged: benefits, benefits realization, disbenefits, Dodge Caliber, Eric Beckinger | 7 Comments »